Look into my eyes and say I am not guilty!
This is a true story. Every word written here is true. It is about communal violence. The story published here is a part of an article that was published in the Diwali number of ‘Nava Manus’ in 2005. Nazim Ali Kadri used to work in the same industry where I also worked.
11th January 1993. Some miscreants broke open the roof of Nazim Ali Kadri’s house. Some were banging his door from outside, trying to force it open. Kadri did not open the door. The communal riots [following Babri masjid demolition] in Mumbai had taken a violent turn. It looked as if the riots were subsiding but the Kadri family lived in fear. He realized that his worst fears had come true. He hid his daughter in the toilet and locked it from outside.
The mob entered, they assaulted Kadri family with swords and knifes. Kadri’s wife intervened and tried to stop them but she too was not spared. They stabbed Kadri’s college going son.
Kadri ran to Dr. Badwaik’s Hospital carrying his son in his arms. He met a nice man in the rikshawala who took them to hospital although both Kadri and his son were bleeding profusely. They moved from Badwaik Hospital to Government Hospital in Mulund and from there to Sion Hospital on the same day for medical attention.
Kadri’s wife was so worried about her husband that she did not move away from his bed in the Sion hospital at all. Terror had gripped them and they were still trying to come to terms with the reality. Kadri moved from the Hospital to his brother’s home in Police quarters at Naigaum [in Mumbai]. He was safe there.
As soon as I learned about Kadri’s ordeal, I went to see him. I can never forget my meeting with Kadri. He was staying with is brother in his police quarters on second or perhaps on the third floor. It was not a very well illuminated drawing room, paint had lost its colour and shine long back and was sparsely furnished. It was a very depressing milieu.
Kadri was sitting on a mat. He was wearing a lungi and had covered his body with towel. I had gone without informing him, he did not know about my visit. He saw me and was moved to tears; he could not speak for quite some time. I also did not know what to say to him. Kadri in that state with wounds everywhere on his body was not a sight I could bring myself to see. Both of us sat there without speaking a word. Not a word exchanged but both of us were fighting back our tears.
Kadri was surely among the most courageous men I have met.
“Sir, they attacked us very badly”, Kadri said and turned around to show his back to me. I could see several hits of the sharp blades of weapons. A baked potato has deep cuts; Kadri’s back reminded me of it. At least twenty five cuts I thought I saw. No, there is no exaggeration in this; I saw a quite a few cuts on his head too. I wondered how he survived that attack, only Allah can tell us I said to myself.
I have seen the Hindu-Muslim violence very closely as I used to stay at Kalyan. I have seen houses set on fire. I have seen families leaving their homes and fleeing Bhiwandi. But nobody known to me was ever injured. Unless somebody close to us is injured we tend to be indifferent to violence around us. [Perhaps it suits us to be indifferent which is so unfortunate!]
Kadri’s wife was not at home when I reached their Naigaum house. She was at their neighbour’s place. She returned hurriedly as soon as she came to know about my arrival. She went to kitchen and brought a jug of water and placed it between Kadri and me. She was returning to kitchen when Kadri called her back.
“Wait, do not go” he said. Turning to me Kadri said, “Look at her wounds”. Kadri’s wife showed me wounds around her neck, cheeks and on forehead. There were wounds on her back too. The assailants had hit her with meat chopper.
During the strike at our factory I had heard a word used commonly by our workmen; it was ‘Half murder’. I thought it was funny and had laughed heartily wondering how a murder can be ‘half’. But now I was seeing what the workmen meant when they said ‘Half murder’.
Kadri’s wife refused to return to their home in Bhandup, Mumbai. Kadri accepted her decision and looked for another residential accommodation.
Seeing his plight I felt that he needed financial help. I spoke to the union committee. I suggested that all employees including managers can contribute some amount. Nobody from union said no but they did not say yes either. If staff and workmen had collected some amount to help him I could have obtained some help from the management too. But all union committee members maintained studied silence. The irony is that Kadri was a member of that union [interestingly that was Bharatiya Kamgar Sena, a Shivsena Union] and was also a shop steward for several years.
The company provided some financial help. But my failure to persuade the union committee members to help Kadri makes me sad whenever I think of it.
* * * * *
January 11, 2004. It was sheer coincidence that Kadri had come over to my residence to meet me. Down with slipped disc, I was at home for almost two months. He had come to know of my illness and he came over to see me. We discussed about our days at the factory. Suddenly Kadri exclaimed “Oh, it was exactly ten years ago that we were assaulted”. And we remembered our meeting at his Naigaum residence.
“Did you know the assailants?” I asked him. The answer shocked me.
“They were not our neighbours and I did not even know them, they were strangers to us,” Kadri said. He continued,”You know that I had shifted my residence to my brother’s place at Naigaum after the assault on us. Everyday I would commute to work by ‘local’ train to Bhandup from Dadar. One day I boarded a local train and saw who was seated in front of me. He was the same person who had assaulted me and my family! He saw me; he was surprised, his eyes almost popped out. He grew uncomfortable, got up and moved out and got down at the next station.
“He could not sit there and look into my eyes! Guilty mind,” Kadri said!
Vivek
A great story. With a lesson.
I really hope everything is OK with Mr Kadri and his family today; the physical wounds may heal, but he is probably mentally scarred for life. And it takes a lot of guts to recognize your assailant and control yourself…
When will we learn that we are used as pawns by the power hungry, and discarded when they get what they want ? At the lowest level, there appears to be no problem coexisting people-to-people.
Lets hope a lesson has been learnt since then…..
The story of Kadri left a mark in me when it was first narrated to me. The lump in my throat is as big, as i read it all over again, and try to live those moments through Kadri’s senses : eyes, nose, ears, touch !
How must it have been to be there !
Your narration is gripping as well. With very vivid descriptions of what happened, making the reader, sprint from one word to the next.
In our current day milieu, it is real life narrations such as these that will sensitise and perhaps leave an imprint in minds. For the good !!
You brought tears to my eyes. I cannot imagine what your friend and his wife and family went through. This is horrible. Half-Murder. I shall remember this term and fear that this happens.
I cannot believe he saw the assailant. Maybe I would have been shocked into not moving, but part of me wonders if I wouldn’t have attacked in retaliation at that moment. It was a brave thing to not have done so, to attack in return, and I’m glad that the assailant had to get up and move. Shame on him, may it follow him long after the train ride…
My prayers go to your friend and his family…
This is cruel gift from or rather misdeed of our politicians whose survival is depends on the hatred feelings of flocks. They just have to instigate people to gain POWER which is used for the selfish purpose.
It is a real misfortune that our law if incapable or insufficient to punish the persons responsible for such inhumanly behavior.
Nothing in the world can replace the loss people have suffered thru and the pain and agony faced during those riots.
We all must be ashamed of it.
Sir,
During the Gujarat riots my Gujarati speaking friends said these people had it coming and such an action was long overdue. Not one single person in that group could articulate a single clear reason that could ever support such an action (there can never be one) but, they stuck to their stand.
I had heard such similar stands being taken during the anti-Sikh riots in Delhi. As always, it is the innocent Kadris of this world who pay for a demented mind of a politician.
An interesting quote (slightly cynical) that I came across “It is not the bullet with my name on it that worries me. It is the one that says ‘To whom it may concern'”.
Dear Aleta, Ugich Konitari, Kavi, Harekrishnaji and Partha,
Thanks for your comments and raising some very important points. Compassion, a sense of anger and frustration is what we are left with when we see victims of such riots.
Thanks again,
Vivek
I am reeling from the reading of Mr Kadri’s story, what a terrible experience for him and his family to go through. I’m sure though that at some point all the assailants involved in the attack will be punished somehow… If not in this life then in another… As Mr. Kadri said, he has and will continue to have, ‘A guilty mind’!
Cheers, Kate .
Kadri is now retired and has settled in his village. I read recently [I do not know whether this is true] that kadris are basically sufis who are known to be forgiving and saintly. I too hope he is fine. His injured son works as a manager in an insurance company now and they are seeing better days, thanks to India shining story. Thanks Kate.
Vivek
Dear Sir,
I have heard the story from you as well as from Kadri. Its deeply touching, and heart rending.
The story reminded me of my visit to Rajkot after the Godhra riots. I saw the third, sixth , seventh and ninth shops amongst a row of shops destroyed to smithereens.Muslim shops – picked and chosen for desecration.
I can only say ‘some part of me died that day’.
It is wrong to say that terrorism has on religion, particularly when both the cause & the perpetrators are connected to religion.
All forms of terrorism is a crime against the humanity, however terror of mighty from the majority community is particularly gruesome.
Dear Sir,
I believe by now you would know me as Kavi has discussed about me with you.
A very heart rending story. Sad but this reality in India and reality is not always very pleasant.
Your story again opened all those horror and violence faced during the riots. I was working for the company in Goregaon Depot and remember on the 9th/10th Dec. 1993 going towards goregaon and the train stopped at Andheri railway crossing. On both sides there were angry mobs standing with the implements which you have mentioned in your post. Of course the few passengers in the compartment managed to shut it and hold tight till we passed the area safely.
What I can’t still comprehend is the ultimate gains of the actions of this mobs. Which community benefits by loss of innocent lives and also the resultant loss of families?
Also your post reminded of that infamous strike which I shall not mention here, for that will not be proper.
You can contact me at 98 457 30656 else ganesh.balaraman@gmail.com